My name is Tisaiwale Chekumbutso. Before I left, my coworkers threw me a surprise goodbye party, and gave me a Malawian name; I felt incredibly honoured. It means “Let us not forget good memories”.
Having returned to Canada, I’ve had some time to reflect upon my experience in Malawi. I have to restrain from pulling my hair when people ask, “How was your trip?” because I always feel as though “trip” refers to a vacation. It wasn’t a trip. I stayed in one country, in one region, in one town, for almost four months. And I learned so much. The people I became close to, the culture, and the sense of community are a few of the many things I will miss.
Of course, I promised myself and others that I would share my experience in different ways, and the fact that I never managed to conclude my blog updates has not gone unnoticed by several people. So here I am, finally settling the nagging feeling that hasn’t disappeared since reuniting with Canada. I’ll put this blog to rest, and continue this new journey of sharing that involves face-to-face interactions with people in Canada. The blog was intended to connect Malawi and Canada, and now that I’m back, it makes little sense to continue. I think part of the reason I never finished is that I had trouble leaving Malawi; I didn’t want to let go. My mind is now in Canada and schoolwork, my body is physically in Canada and Nova Scotia, but my heart is still across the Atlantic, and I don’t think part of it will ever leave.
A few days into school, during orientation week, I received an email from a co-worker at Concern Universal. Apparently, my 69-year old host grandmother Agogo had just died. This news spread through the small community in the Dedza township, which reached my friend who runs a tiny restaurant near the bus depot (he was the one who helped me find a host family). My co-worker who occasionally eats at the restaurant found out from my friend with the restaurant and later emailed me. This really hit hard because I vividly remember making the tough decision to pay $45 for a two-week hospital stay in Lilongwe because the government hospital in Dedza didn’t have the resources to treat her illness. It was a tough decision because I could have spent the $45 on something impact, perhaps on younger individuals who “hadn’t already outlived their life expectancy in Malawi”, as one Canadian friend described it. But the thing with development is that we cannot follow a set of rules that call us to always make the practical, sensible choice of maximizing utility for all people. The ideal of maximizing impact (i.e. with time, money, other resources) sometimes gets thrown out the careening minibus window where personal relationships are involved, which I why I ended up helping my host family pay for their grandmother’s hospital treatment.
To refocus, I think I’ll go about describing what happened with my placement this summer, in terms of work. Some people have been emailing me, still confused about what I was doing – and rightly so, because I don’t think I was ever clear about that.
I was working within the rather complicated hierarchy at Concern Universal – and this was only at one field office! I wasn’t even at the national office…
Acronyms:
HSA – Health Surveillance Assistant
VHWC – Village Health and Water Committee
CU – Concern Universal
TMO – Training and Monitoring Officer
CBM – Community Based Management
WSF – Water Environment and Sanitation Facilitator
NGO – Non-Government Organization
M&E – Monitoring and Evaluation
WESP – Water Environment and Sanitation Program
DC - District Coordinator
The basis of my placement centered about three work streams, which essentially formed the goals for the outputs of my placement. For my coworkers’ privacy, I’m not going to their names or positions, especially those whom I worked closely with. And trust me, working as a Junior Fellow wasn't nearly as put together as the following description of the placement sounds. I've just have some time form to form my thoughts since then...
As I mentioned before, I was partnered with Concern Universal (CU), which is the largest NGO implementer of water and sanitation projects in Malawi. I worked at CU’s field office in the Dedza region, about 1.5 hours south of Malawi’s capital city, Lilongwe. Concern Universal’s national office is in Blantyre but there are several field offices throughout Malawi. The basis of my placement centered about three work streams that were partially structured beforehand by CU’s country director, CU’s WESP manager, and CU’s two TMOs, in addition to three long-term EWB volunteers who have worked or are currently working with CU. Janelle Murray, another EWB Junior Fellow (who worked at CU’s Ntcheu field office), also followed these three work streams. Working with CU and its wonderful staff was an incredible, invaluable learning experience.
The first of the three work streams was the primary focus of my work. This involved conducting a rigorous field-level analysis of the improved monitoring and evaluation (M&E) system that was designed and implemented by past EWB volunteers. I conducted field-level research in Dedza while Janelle conducted similar research in Ntcheu. Janelle Murray (working in Ntcheu) and I collaborated to develop a research plan which involved designing the research methodology; for example, village level transect walks to cross-check M&E data, separate semi-structured interviews, and surveys with various field-level stakeholders (TMO, WSFs, HSAs, VHWCs). We then reported back to Concern Universal on the effectiveness of the system at ground-level, external factors affecting the system’s functionality, and strengths and weaknesses of the system. We then made recommendations for the current system which included viable solutions to the identified bottlenecks, and tried to synthesize the lessons learnt from the system’s implementation phase into recommendations for future M&E systems similar to or based on this system. The entire point of our doing this was to fit in with the context of the work that the long-term volunteers are doing in Malawi; essentially, making sure this M&E system is working or not.
The second of the three work streams was a smaller focus of work. This involved providing computer skills training, focusing on Microsoft Word, Excel, PowerPoint, and Access. The purpose of this training was to build on the existing skills by teaching time-saving tricks and to increase the level of managing, processing, analytical, and reporting on data from the M&E database. The third of the three work streams involved coaching in professional skills development. This posed some learning curves, given my limited experience working with any sort of people in management positions, but I stumbled around a bit and eventually found my feet.
The most rewarding part about working, at least immediately, was the people I met and developed relationships with. After all, we are primarily accountable to Dorothy, who represents the people we are working for; and secondarily accountable to our NGO coworkers. And of course, we are responsible to EWB (but I take that as a given).
But here comes another question that some people, including myself, have been wondering....
What about us, in Canada? Do we all have to go overseas to make an impact? In my opinion: Not at all. As Owen Scott (an EWB volunteer in Zambia) put it:
“If you want to change the world, please don't rush overseas and try to make a difference. Stop, think, learn, think some more, and if you're still sure you want to go, and can articulate why you want to go, what you're trying to do, and what are the possible positive and negative outcomes and impacts from your planned actions, then please go and I'd say Zambia/Africa is lucky to have you.
So what else can people do? Really, infinite things. If you want to volunteer overseas, then put a little thought into it and you'll probably end up doing some really good work. If you want to work in Canada, then join an EWB chapter, or go to a protest, or write a letter to your MP, or read a book on development, or donate to a charity, or basically do anything that you feel is worthwhile (here are some more ideas). I will, in about a week, add my own page of links to this blog for people who want to learn more. The fight against poverty won't be over quickly, and so sustained passionate action on many fronts is what's needed. If everyone plays their part then maybe in 20 years stories like the one I told about my friend in Zambia will be firmly in the past.”
In Ivan Illich’s somewhat controversial (and in my opinion, a bit cynical) speech “To Hell with Good Intentions” about volunteering thoughtlessly in developing countries, he has some interesting things to say which I find quite thought-provoking. It isn’t specific to Africa, but it makes one stop and think about why we work overseas and what we are trying to do.
"If you have any sense of responsibility at all, stay with your riots here at home. Work for the coming elections: You will know what you are doing, why you are doing it, and how to communicate with those to whom you speak. And you will know when you fail. If you insist on working with the poor, if this is your vocation, then at least work among the poor who can tell you to go to hell. It is incredibly unfair for you to impose yourselves on a village where you are so linguistically deaf and dumb that you don't even understand what you are doing, or what people think of you. And it is profoundly damaging to yourselves when you define something that you want to do as 'good,' a 'sacrifice' and 'help.' I am here to suggest that you voluntarily renounce exercising the power which being an American gives you. I am here to entreat you to freely, consciously and humbly give up the legal right you have to impose your benevolence on Mexico. I am here to challenge you to recognize your inability, your powerlessness and your incapacity to do the "good" which you intended to do. I am here to entreat you to use your money, your status and your education to travel in Latin America. Come to look, come to climb our mountains, to enjoy our flowers. Come to study. But do not come to help."
I urge you not to feel cynical about his speech, but to think about alternate ways we can be active in human development here in Canada. I strongly believe that volunteering in Africa isn’t necessarily the ultimate solution. Far from it. As Canadians, we have work to do here. There are so many barriers to development, such as Tied Aid (which, by the way, the government finally committed to eliminating after years of campaigning!), unfair subsidies, and restrictions on trade. Depending on each of our skills, interests, and capabilities, we can all work on something different for a common goal. For some people, working in a developing country will transform them into development champions or a lifelong development worker. For others, becoming educated and changing our workplace or community into a more global-minded environment is the best way of creating change. For yet others, achieving success in a career and donating to effective charities will be their role. And for others, becoming politically active or a voice for those without will be their calling. But for all of us, we can make small daily changes in our lives in many different ways, which have an impact in the long-run.
As Canadians in Canada, we can…
• Spur technological innovation – we have the financial wealth and a wealth of knowledge to research solutions to problems in developing countries
• Travel and learn about poverty and share with Canadians, but in a way that is not thoughtless and damaging – there is some merit in being exposed to developing countries
• Travel to experience new cultures and simultaneously break down the stereotypes that contribute to prejudice, bigotry, and apathy towards people in developing countries (e.g. the westerner coming in to ‘help’ the poor, helpless people)
• Lobby western governments to make smart choices about where to focus in regards to international affairs – and how best to use money directed towards international development initiatives (i.e. get rid of Tied-Aid)
• Continually learn about development – we have access to an incredible amount of information, and can use things like the Internet to educate ourselves by keeping up-to-date on current global events and international development news
• Direct charitable donations to the right places – there are thousands of NGOs and a million more ways to spend money, but we can learn about where our money will have the greatest impact
• Buy consumer goods responsibly – taking care to think about the effects of our actions and trying to maximize the benefit of our purchases (i.e. buying Fair Trade products)
I would like to add something that another JF, Binnu, said, because she says it so well (and I would urge you to check out her blog):
"So what did I learn over the last 4 months from all these people that I met in Malawi? Well, a lot. But the one thing that really stands out is the realization that poverty is complex and will take a long time to combat, and the people on the forefront of this combat are the people of these developing communities. They are the real agents of change, but that doesn’t absolve us of our responsibility. As Paul Collier, author of the Bottom Billion said, “We can help the reformers in these societies who are struggling for change, that’s one modest role .”What would this modest role look like? It could range anywhere from making more responsible consumer choices (buying fair trade coffee to ensure fair wages to farmers or driving less to help reduce the hike in fuel prices) to using the upcoming elections to make sure that our candidates have a plan for more and better development aid from Canada. Below are a few web-sites you can check for some inspiration on what you could do:
http://www.ewb.ca/en/whatyoucando/index.html [suggestions for action from Engineers Without Borders]
http://www.results-resultats.ca/action/actions/default-en.aspx [influencing the Canadian government]
http://www.makepovertyhistory.ca/en/take-action [promoting the cause of international development]
http://transfair.ca/en/fairtradeproducts and http://transfair.ca/en/ethicalpolicy [making fair-trade consumer choices]
drive less for poverty article [exploring other ways to alleviate poverty]"
And here I’m not trying to be preachy or anything, but I really think that everyone inherently wants to make a difference, even if that difference is simply buying a cup of Fair Trade coffee that increases the income of farmers in a Fair Trade cooperative. Poverty still exists. And poverty – I don’t believe – is a thing either. Poverty is people. Poverty is all the people who are vulnerable to external factors out of their control and who lack the opportunity to create a safety net for themselves. Poverty is Amandiwe Tchawuya, a 56-year old woman who delivers thousands of babies and raises her daughter and her grandchildren by herself while farming for a living. Poverty is the father who smuggles bundles of charcoal from Mozambique to earn a living so he can send his children to secondary school. Poverty is the girl who just lost her husband to AIDS. Poverty is the boy who wanders around the bus depot selling used, washed plastic bags from one hand and ripe bananas from the other hand. These people are the faces of poverty, but that’s not all. They are also hope, courage, strength, joy, love, and so many other things that we often forget about when we think of these individuals. And I think, most importantly, these individuals are similar to us in so many ways. I’m posting a video of my 18-year old host brother, Juseck, who is an orphan taken in by my host family who currently can’t afford to send him to secondary school ( I wrote about him in my last post). He is a smart, endearing goofball, and I love this video because it highlights how all people just love to be silly sometimes, especially with their family members - no matter what country they are from. One day Juseck asked to learn how to use a camera, so I brought mine out reluctantly and spent 10 minutes teaching him how to point-and-shoot and take video clips. I then lent him the camera for the weekend because he wanted to borrow it to try out, and he surprised me by interviewing all the family members to give me something to remember everyone by. And he added this goofy dancing video too which I didn’t discover until I was back in Canada....
Oh, and the answer to that quiz I posted a long time ago is “Ndili chachiwisi.” Hah.... so most of you got it wrong – or just went with the majority vote! “Ndili chachiwisi” means “I am fresh”.
Thank you so much to everyone and goodbye. Zikomo kwambiri ndi ndapita.







































